Book Review: Mood Machine by Liz Pelly
Liz Pelly’s Mood Machine: The Rise of Spotify and the Costs of the Perfect Playlist is a meticulously researched indictment of Spotify’s impact on music culture and economics. Pelly paints a clear picture of how the streaming giant’s business model driven by algorithms and the pursuit of profit has fundamentally changed how we experience music, often to the detriment of both artists and listeners.
The Heart of the Critique
Pelly’s central argument is that Spotify cares little about music as art and instead treats it as raw data to be mined for user engagement and advertising revenue. The book details how curated playlists, especially those designed to fit a particular mood, promote a passive “lean-back listening” culture, reducing music to a background utility rather than a creative force. She unearths the platform’s pay-for-play schemes, “ghost artists,” and the absurdly small revenue that reaches actual musicians, which paints a bleak picture for the future of music creation and appreciation.
Insights and Reception
Several reviewers appreciated the book’s depth and sharp insights, particularly Pelly’s investigative approach to Spotify’s business machinations. The book explores Spotify’s origins not as a music company, but as an advertising enterprise, with music serving merely as bait to attract user data. Pelly’s detailed account of how major labels have profited while independent musicians struggle is both compelling and damning.
However, some readers found the book repetitive, with certain chapters rehashing earlier points instead of introducing new perspectives. The “ambient music” focus, which Pelly uses as a central metaphor for modern listening habits, drew criticism for being overemphasized compared to its actual presence on the platform. The writing sometimes veers into judgmental territory regarding passive listening, which could alienate readers who enjoy background music without guilt.
Strengths and Weaknesses
- Strengths:
- Thorough and passionate research into Spotify’s effects on music.
- Insightful chapters on playlist manipulation, ghost artists, and industry lobbying.
- Chilling exposure of the platform’s algorithmic influence and data mining priorities.
- Weaknesses:
- Some sections repeat arguments, adding bulk without new insight.
- The focus on mood/ambient playlists occasionally overshadows broader industry analysis.
- At times, Pelly’s indie-rooted nostalgia feels overly romantic and dismissive of financial realities for modern musicians.
Verdict
Mood Machine is not a comfortable read, but it is an essential one for anyone who cares about music’s future and the economics shaping artistic expression. While its depth may overwhelm casual readers, those invested in the topic will find it both enraging and illuminating. Pelly doesn’t offer clear solutions, but her meticulous unmasking of Spotify’s business model is a clarion call for change and a warning about the costs of our ever-more personalized playlists.
About The Author
